Back to steven-hall.org
Welcome Guest Search | Active Topics | Members | Log In | Register

Deleted Scene from Powell's Books Options
MiaVRO
Posted: Monday, February 04, 2008 11:57:07 AM

Rank: Bede Shark
Groups: Shoal

Joined: 1/24/2009
Posts: 256
Location: Canada
So, i was searching around some Steven Hall stuff and I came across his Powell's Books blog, and there's something he described as a 'deleted scene' or alternate ending to the book in one of his blogs. its probably here on the forum somewhere, but i couldn't really find it, and I don't know how to attach a link to a website (maybe someone can help me out with that), so i'm just going to copy and past it.
http://www.powells.com/blog/?p=1939--more-1939
CpVb006
Posted: Tuesday, February 24, 2009 8:48:28 PM

Rank: Shoal
Groups: Shoal , Unspace Science Committee

Joined: 1/24/2009
Posts: 139
Location: United States
I think this is actually pretty interesting/discussion worthy. Definitely something I'll stick in the Red Cabinet once I can post there again.

I remember Steven mentioning that in some editions there was (or maybe it was just planned but never came about) an extra passage at the end, but the majority of them had been physically cut out.

I think it's likely that text is what we're seeing at this link, especially because he mentioned that he felt it "upset the balance of information and ambiguity" in Chapter 36.
Steven Hall
Posted: Wednesday, February 25, 2009 3:24:08 PM

Rank: Whale Shark
Groups: Shoal , Whale Shark

Joined: 1/24/2009
Posts: 310
Location: UK
Hey folks,

Just so nobody gets confused about this one - this is very much a deleted scene in that it was dropped from the manuscript in favour of the ending that ended up in there. It isn't extra content in the way the negatives are, really it's just a curio - an abandoned concept. I figured people might like to see an ending-that-never-was and have a glimpse into one of the other directions the book might have taken.

I have a few more adandoned concepts like this but I've held on to them so far because I think it'd be very easy for people to get mixed up between this stuff and the negatives/fragments etc. The abandoned concepts all live in a file on my desktop called 'Things That Didn't Happen', so I can keep a close eye on em. :)


S
heartbreak
Posted: Wednesday, February 25, 2009 3:40:36 PM
Rank: Unspace Science Committee
Groups: Shoal , Unspace Science Committee

Joined: 1/24/2009
Posts: 215
Thank you! I've always had a bit of an aversion to alternate endings showing up on DVDs and could never peg down why. You've explained it exactly. I also like the name of your folder. The folders on my desktop do not have such interesting titles.
CpVb006
Posted: Friday, March 20, 2009 1:20:15 AM

Rank: Shoal
Groups: Shoal , Unspace Science Committee

Joined: 1/24/2009
Posts: 139
Location: United States
Just wanted to post the article text here for posterity/preservation, incase that page ever gets taken down. Don't mind me.

- - -

"First up, a rare attempt at clarity. I feel like I should say that when I started off my first blog on Monday like this —

Ahhh blogging, that fantastic digital mash-up of random thoughts, half-baked product placement, free stuff and alcohol-induced slander.

— I was talking about how I approach my own blog writing (or, more accurately, how my own blogs always seem to turn out!), I was speaking about myself, not passing judgement on anyone else!

As anyone who keeps an eye on my MySpace page knows, I've been happily blogging away there for the past 6 months and my blogs on the whole are pretty much as advertised above (with the exemption of the slander, which is something I'm still working my way up to.).

So sorry for any confusion, and a special sorry to the nice folks at babygotbooks.com who despite taking those comments to heart a little bit, still gave my book a very decent plug. Thanks guys, I have a kitten blood special edition here on my desk waiting for you if you want it. Give me a shout

So — I made my train yesterday, with all the usual last minute rushing about and panic. The train got about halfway to Manchester, stopped at some signals and decided not to start again for about 20 minutes, which didn't help my panic levels much. I made it to the event, though, and really enjoyed it — thanks to everyone who came along. It's so great to get to meet people who've read my book and really got something out of it. I think the internet is really helpful on that front, too — before websites and MySpace it must have been a very weird experience for an author to put a book out and, apart from a few readings and maybe some fan mail, never have any contact with the people who've read it! My MySpace page does take up a fair amount of time but I wouldn't be without it. Actually, I think I might be addicted, but that's another story...

I'm now on yet another train, hurtling at high speed through the English countryside towards London and typing this on the thumb-crampingly tiny keyboard on my mobile phone. (And feeling a bit sick!) I've never been on a train quite like this one, it's small, sort of condensed like a plane, and opposite me there's a little tiny little office with a computer in it where the guards hang out and have a laugh as if they'd never suspect there were passengers around to overhear what they were saying. It's all a bit surreal. I'm trying not to think about it.

So, to finish off on, I thought I'd post up a deleted scene from The Raw Shark Texts. It's actually what would have been the very end of the book, but I took it out because I felt it upset the balance of information and ambiguity I was going for in the final chapter. I guess it pretty much amounts to an alternative ending. Here it is, just for fun...

Quote:
Dear Dr Randle,

I must have written this letter at least twenty times now. Some drafts have been almost as long as the document enclosed, full of notes, tables and flowcharts running over seven or eight sides of A4. I'd have to order five frappes just to pin them down to the table and still they kept blowing away. It's probably for the best. With the way words work, I always end up de-saying half of what I tried to say and anyway my girlfriend has started adding her own bubbles to the charts with I am a geek written in them.

So, to business. (and I'm choosing my words very carefully):

If there is a Dr Randle out there, if you've ever met me, if you receive this parcel, then the enclosed account is yours. Take whatever you want from it and interpret it however suits you, you're free to find whatever meaning you like. All I ask in return is that you don't come looking for me. Please make sure I am left alone and if anyone ever asks you what happened to me, where I am now, how things turned out in the end then please just tell them this:

I am home.

Thank you.

Without regret or any need of hope,

Eric Sanderson


Thanks for reading, folks...

S"
cgsheldon
Posted: Friday, March 20, 2009 5:14:33 PM
Rank: Luxophage
Groups: Shoal

Joined: 1/24/2009
Posts: 127
Location: Dubai, UAE
I think Steven was right to leave this letter out of the book; I prefer the ambiguous nature of the postcard. That said, it is interesting to discuss in the context of the novel.

Quote:
If there is a Dr Randle out there, if you've ever met me, if you receive this parcel, then the enclosed account is yours. Take whatever you want from it and interpret it however suits you, you're free to find whatever meaning you like.


The "enclosed account" is presumably referring to the text that became Raw Shark; Dr. Randle isn't presented in a very professional way in the novel (meeting Eric at her home numerous times; failing to encourage him to seek medical help that wasn't retired; and, if what Mr. Nobody said was true, she was using Eric in order to write a paper on him and achieve fame for herself). This sets aside the newspaper clipping at the end which may have been included in the parcel by Eric, or was included later before the edited text was published.

If this deleted scene were taken as canon I'd ask if Dr. Randle ever received the parcel. If she did, she certainly seems to have been big enough to leave her parts intact. If she didn't receive the parcel, then someone, like Mr. Webster or Mr. Hall, somehow intercepted it.

Assuming the parcel is an unedited version of Raw Shark, both Mr. Webster's Bookzer0 and Mr. Hall's collection seem to have aspects of it.

A Frappe is a Greek coffee.
Users browsing this topic
Guest


Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Main Forum RSS : RSS

Website Maintained by Paul A.T. Wilson (Xplosiv Media)
Powered by Yet Another Forum.net version 1.9.1.8 (NET v2.0) - 3/29/2008
Copyright © 2003-2008 Yet Another Forum.net. All rights reserved.
This page was generated in 0.068 seconds.